Review: Islander C5 Centerpin Reel

Growing up fishing the Niagara River, Islander reels have been my go-to for many years. Between rough shorelines, unpredictable currents, and nearly year-round use, gear had to endure years of abuse while still performing flawlessly. That’s what Islander has been known for over the last several decades, and why their reels have earned such loyalty, including my own.

For me, that loyalty was cemented with my Steelheader Centerpin reel that I’ve used for about 10 years, and it has never failed me. It’s been through extreme conditions and countless battles and has helped make memories that will last a lifetime. So, when Islander released the new C5 in early 2025, I knew I had to get my hands on one.

Breaking in the C5 Centerpin Reel

When I bought the C5, I didn’t want its first run to be just another day on the river. So, I let it sit for nearly two months before spooling it, saving it for a trip up to the Skeena tributaries in Northern BC.

Some anglers believe in the omen of never hooking a fish on your first drift, but I was ready this time, as I often do a false cast to start—I can thank Joey Dicenzo for getting that stuck in my head years ago. First cast, the reel performed effortlessly, setting me up on a perfect seam at roughly my ten o’clock. Sure enough—first drift, first hookup, first fish. To christen the reel with a steelhead on that stretch of water was exactly the start I had hoped for.

When the fish bolted toward the tailout, I realized just how valuable the C5’s 5″ spool really is. The added pickup power gave me more control and let me gain line whenever I had the chance. After about a 5-minute (ish) battle, the fish was landed. Of course, I had to snap a picture with both the fish and my new reel—a moment tying together performance, beauty, and memory.

What Sets the C5 Centerpin Reel Apart

Islander designed the C5 with refinement in mind. It’s not a reinvention but a polished evolution of what already works, with a new look. Here’s what stood out to me:

• Ultra-Smooth Drifts: The C5’s shielded, low-friction bearings minimize startup inertia. Even in light current, the spool engages naturally, making long, clean drifts effortless. This was noticeable right away. With some line management and mending, you’re perfectly on top of your float and keeping with the natural flow.
• Faster Line Retrieval: That extra half-inch in diameter may not seem like much on paper, but on the water it translates to quicker pickup. When a fish runs downstream or slack line builds, the difference is immediate.
• Travel Lock: A simple yet brilliant addition. With a quick shift of the lever on the back of the reel, your reel lock gets tighter, preventing line from spilling out. If you’ve ever hiked through the bush without a reel cover, you’ll know the frustration of clicking, slipping line, and bouncing weights. With the C5, that hassle is gone.
• Brass Click Lever: A big upgrade over the Steelheader’s clicker. I believe Islander listened to users and made this change to better suit our needs.
• Ambidextrous Design: Like the Steelheader, the C5 is non-directional but emphasizes tool-free switching between right- and left-hand retrieve. A nice touch for versatility.
• Refined Machining: The ported frame keeps the reel strong yet balanced, reducing unnecessary weight.
• Hand-Built Assurance: Each C5 is assembled and tested by Islander’s team on Vancouver Island, backed by a two-year warranty. That human touch adds to its character.

 

Comparing the Steelheader and the C5

Having used both extensively, I don’t see the C5 as a replacement for the Steelheader but as its natural evolution. The Steelheader remains a rock-solid workhorse: dependable, smooth, and built to last. It’s been the standard for performance and durability for years, and it still delivers exactly what most anglers need.

Where the C5 steps ahead is in the details. The larger spool means faster pickup and more control in heavy water. The improved bearings make startup even smoother, especially in subtle drifts where every bit of natural presentation counts. The travel lock is a convenience seasoned anglers will quickly appreciate. And the brass lever is proof Islander listens to feedback and is committed to technical improvement.

To put it simply, my Steelheader isn’t leaving my arsenal. It now rides on my backup rod, which comes with me on every trip. For finesse setups like running a shot line over slip weights, the C5 will be my go-to. But when I’m hopping down rugged shorelines, fishing deep pockets that hold fast water, and short runs, I know exactly which reel I’ll reach for—my Steelheader.

Final Thoughts

After breaking it in on the Skeena, I can confidently say the C5 isn’t just another reel—it’s a new chapter for Islander.

It takes everything Islander has built its reputation on and layers in refinements you notice right away. It’s smooth, powerful, and thoughtfully designed for anglers who demand the most from their gear. Not to mention it looks pretty damn good on my custom CTS Affinity rod built by Pete Raeburn, who initially introduced me to Island Fisherman magazine more than 15 years ago back home in Niagara.

The Steelheader will always hold a place in my heart—it’s the reel that’s been with me for the last decade. But the C5 shows where Islander is headed, and it’s an exciting direction. For those considering the jump, my advice is simple: get it in your hands, give it a spin, and feel the quality for yourself.

Bottom line: The C5 is Islander’s new statement piece. It’s not here to replace the Steelheader, but to complement it, showcasing tangible evolution within the brand and providing a smoother experience and drift.

Tight lines from the shorelines!

-Luke

Islander C5 Awarded Island Fisherman Gear of the Year

“Islander has long set the standard for reels, and the new C5 shows they are committed to not just maintaining that legacy, but pushing it forward,” said Joel Unickow, Owner of Island Fisherman magazine. “Our ‘Gear of the Year’ award is reserved for products that offer a genuine, noticeable improvement for the angler, and the C5 delivers. The combined smoothness, control from the larger spool, and smart additions like the travel lock make it a truly worthy winner that we confidently recommend to our readership. We are proud to honour them with our award.”

This article appeared in Island Fisherman magazine, never miss another issue—Subscribe today!